Friday, December 31, 2010

Tennessee’s mental errors cost Vols in thrilling Music City Bowl

All the credit should, and surely will, go to Butch Davis and his players. It should also be pointed out that UNC quarterback T.J. Yates is one helluva gamer. For all the NCAA distractions from earlier this year, coupled with the criticisms of his inconsistencies and cries for a change at QB, Yates has persevered and led a dramatic 31-second comeback at the end of regulation.
It should also be noted that North Carolina got a little help too, and no, not from Big Ten officials. While the last 30 seconds of the game included a few more flags and official reviews than one would hope, we saw the Vols shoot themselves in their foot. If anything, Tennessee might have gotten away with a few unsportsmanlike conduct calls against quarterback Tyler Bray.

The personal foul, leading-with-the-helmet penalty on Tennessee after Todd Harrelson caught a 28-yard pass from Yates on North Carolina’s final drive of regulation was justified, and there was no sufficient evidence to overturn the call on the field of a catch. Arguably, there could have been another personal foul penalty on Tennessee for a late hit one play later on a 12-yard completion to UNC’s Dwight Jones.

The personal foul penalty on Tennessee at the end of regulation, which was assessed 15 yards in favor of UNC in the first overtime, didn’t appear to be fully explained, but it ultimately became part of a larger scheme: Simply put, Tennessee committed too many mental errors and allowed North Carolina to stay in the game.
North Carolina’s game-winning field goal in double overtime was a fitting end to what has been a tumultuous season for both the Tar Heels and the Vols.

1 comment:

Tim said...

There was clearly enough evidence to overturn the Harrelson "catch."

Ball hits hands. Harrelson's foot hits ground.
Jackson hits Harrelson. Harrelson goes airborne. Ball gets jarred loose.
Harrelson's head and shoulders hit the ground out of bounds, at which point Harrelson gains control of the ball.

No catch.